Make room for a longer argument

These original written problems need more than a clicked answer. Choose one, allow 20–45 minutes or longer, and keep a record of failed attempts. The labels describe the methods involved, not an official contest difficulty rating. No automatic score is awarded.

Polynomials · complete classification

A polynomial that always gives a prime

Let P have integer coefficients. Suppose P(n) is a positive prime for every integer n. Prove that P is constant.

Hint 1: a starting idea

Let p=P(0). What is P(kp) modulo p?

Hint 2: develop the argument

Every value P(kp) is both a positive prime and divisible by p. Turn this into infinitely many roots of one polynomial.

Full solution

Set p=P(0), a positive prime. Every nonconstant term of P(kp) is divisible by p, and the constant term is p. Hence p divides P(kp) for every integer k.

By the hypothesis, P(kp) is a positive prime, so it must equal p. The polynomial Q(x)=P(x)−p therefore has infinitely many distinct roots kp. A nonzero polynomial has at most its degree many distinct roots, so Q is the zero polynomial. Thus P is constantly p. Conversely, every constant positive prime polynomial has the required property.

Revisit the underlying lesson →

Inequalities · equality matters

Three fractions and one sharp bound

For positive a,b,c, prove a/(b+c)+b/(c+a)+c/(a+b)≥3/2, and determine every equality case.

Hint 1: a starting idea

Rewrite a/(b+c) as a²/[a(b+c)].

Hint 2: develop the argument

Use Engel form of Cauchy, then compare (a+b+c)² with 3(ab+bc+ca).

Full solution

Engel form gives the sum at least (a+b+c)²/[2(ab+bc+ca)], since a(b+c)+b(c+a)+c(a+b)=2(ab+bc+ca)>0.

The identity a²+b²+c²−ab−bc−ca=((a−b)²+(b−c)²+(c−a)²)/2≥0 gives (a+b+c)²≥3(ab+bc+ca). Therefore the previous fraction is at least 3/2.

Equality in the second bound requires a=b=c. For these positive equal values each original fraction is 1/2, so equality indeed holds. No other equality case is possible.

Revisit the underlying lesson →

Induction · a construction proof

One missing square, many L-shaped tiles

A 2n2^{n}-by-2n2^{n} board has one unit square removed, where n≥1. Prove that the remaining squares can be tiled by L-shaped trominoes, each made from three unit squares in a 2-by-2 square.

An eight-by-eight board divided into four quadrants, one missing square and a central L-tromino.Dark square: missingGold: one central L-tromino
The central tile occupies one square in each of the three quadrants without the original hole. Each quadrant is now a smaller one-hole problem.
Hint 1: a starting idea

Solve the 2-by-2 case. Then divide a larger board into four equal quadrants.

Hint 2: develop the argument

The original missing square lies in one quadrant. Place one central tromino so that the other three quadrants each have one square already occupied.

Full solution

For n=1, removing one square from a 2-by-2 board leaves exactly one L-shaped tromino.

Assume every 2k2^{k}-by-2k2^{k} board with one missing square can be tiled. Divide a 2k+12^{k+1}-by-2k+12^{k+1} board into four quadrants. Exactly one contains the original missing square. Place a central L-tromino using the three centre-adjacent squares belonging to the other three quadrants.

Each quadrant now has exactly one square unavailable: the original missing square in one, or the central tromino square in each of the others. Apply the induction hypothesis separately to the four quadrants. These tilings and the central tile cover every remaining square exactly once, proving the result by induction.

Revisit the underlying lesson →

Recurrences · an invariant

Consecutive terms that share no factor

Let a₀=2, a₁=5 and aₙ₊₂=3aₙ₊₁−aₙ for n≥0. Prove aₙaₙ₊₂−aₙ₊₁²=1 for every n≥0, then prove consecutive terms are coprime.

Hint 1: a starting idea

Compute a₂ and test the expression at n=0.

Hint 2: develop the argument

Call the expression Iₙ. Substitute the recurrence to compare Iₙ₊₁ with Iₙ.

Full solution

The recurrence gives a₂=13, so I₀=2·13−5²=1. For any n, Iₙ₊₁=aₙ₊₁aₙ₊₃−aₙ₊₂²=3aₙ₊₁aₙ₊₂−aₙ₊₁²−aₙ₊₂².

Since aₙ=3aₙ₊₁−aₙ₊₂, the same expression equals aₙaₙ₊₂−aₙ₊₁²=Iₙ. Thus induction gives Iₙ=1 for every n.

Any positive common divisor of aₙ and aₙ₊₁ divides aₙaₙ₊₂−aₙ₊₁²=1, so their greatest common divisor is 1. All terms are integers because the initial values and recurrence are integral.

Revisit the underlying lesson →

Functional equations · necessity and sufficiency

An additive equation with an extra term

Find all functions f from the nonnegative integers to the real numbers satisfying f(m+n)=f(m)+f(n)+2mn for every m,n≥0.

Hint 1: a starting idea

Find f(0), then set n=1 to obtain a recurrence.

Hint 2: develop the argument

Compare f(n) with n², since (m+n)² contains the extra term 2mn.

Full solution

Setting m=n=0 gives f(0)=0. Define g(n)=f(n)−n². Expanding (m+n)² shows g(m+n)=g(m)+g(n) on the nonnegative integers.

Let c=g(1). Induction using g(n+1)=g(n)+c gives g(n)=cn for every n≥0. Hence every possible solution has f(n)=n²+cn for one real constant c.

Conversely, for any real c, the formula f(n)=n²+cn gives f(m+n)=m²+n²+2mn+c(m+n)=f(m)+f(n)+2mn. All real c are therefore permitted. The proof relies on an integer domain; it does not assume continuity.

Revisit the underlying lesson →

Number theory · find all solutions

An equation hidden inside a product

Find all ordered pairs of positive integers (x,y) such that xy=x+y+35.

Hint 1: a starting idea

Move x and y to the left and add 1 to both sides.

Hint 2: develop the argument

The equation becomes (x−1)(y−1)=36. Show both factors are positive before listing all divisor pairs.

Full solution

Rearranging gives (x−1)(y−1)=36. Since x,y are positive integers, both factors are nonnegative. Their product is positive, so each is positive.

Let d=x−1. Then d is a positive divisor of 36, and y−1=36/d. Thus all solutions are (d+1,36/d+1) for d∈{1,2,3,4,6,9,12,18,36}.

The nine ordered pairs are (2,37),(3,19),(4,13),(5,10),(7,7),(10,5),(13,4),(19,3),(37,2). Every listed pair works by reversing the factorisation, and every solution has been captured by a positive divisor.

Revisit the underlying lesson →

Combinatorics and residues · choose the boxes

A divisible consecutive block

Given any list of n integers a₁,…,aₙ with n≥1, prove that some nonempty consecutive block has a sum divisible by n.

Hint 1: a starting idea

Consider the n prefix sums Sₖ=a₁+⋯+aₖ.

Hint 2: develop the argument

If no prefix sum is 0 modulo n, put all n prefix sums into the n−1 nonzero remainder classes.

Full solution

If a prefix sum Sₖ is divisible by n, the block a₁,…,aₖ already works. This also settles n=1.

Otherwise n≥2 and the n prefix sums occupy only n−1 nonzero residue classes modulo n. Pigeonhole gives Sᵢ≡Sⱼ for some i<j.

Subtracting gives aᵢ₊₁+⋯+aⱼ=Sⱼ−Sᵢ≡0 mod n. The block is consecutive and nonempty because j>i. Negative entries cause no difficulty: residues are defined for all integers.

Revisit the underlying lesson →

Geometry · angle chasing and a circle

Reflecting an orthocentre

Let ABC be an acute triangle with orthocentre H. Reflect H across line BC to obtain H′. Prove that H′ lies on the circumcircle of ABC.

Acute triangle ABC with orthocentre H and its reflection H prime across BC on the circumcircle.ABCHH′
Reflect H in BC. Equal angles ∠BHC and ∠BH′C give the supplementary-angle test for the circle. The drawing illustrates the acute case in the problem.
Hint 1: a starting idea

Use BH perpendicular to AC and CH perpendicular to AB to find ∠HBC and ∠HCB.

Hint 2: develop the argument

Compute ∠BHC, then use reflection and the opposite-angle test for a cyclic quadrilateral.

Full solution

Because the triangle is acute, H lies inside it. Perpendicularity gives ∠HBC=90°−∠C and ∠HCB=90°−∠B. The angle sum in BHC yields ∠BHC=180°−[(90°−C)+(90°−B)]=B+C=180°−A.

Reflection across BC fixes B and C and preserves angles, so ∠BH′C=∠BHC=180°−A. The points A and H′ lie on opposite sides of BC. Therefore the convex quadrilateral ABH′C has opposite angles ∠BAC and ∠BH′C summing to 180°.

By the converse cyclic-quadrilateral criterion, A,B,H′,C lie on one circle. This is the circumcircle of ABC, so it contains H′. The acute-triangle assumption keeps the ordinary angle and convexity argument valid as written.

Revisit the underlying lesson →

My proof notebook

Write on paper, or keep a draft here. Compare your reasoning with the solution only after a real attempt. The checklist is your own review, not an automatic mark.